wind/rain deflectors - VW or third party?

[Eric1]

Ignoring cost, which is the best type of deflector? The VW type that stick on the frame, or the third party type that are inserted into the sill and held with clips? Do they all work OK with a wrap round windscreen cover? Thanks

 

[Perfectos]

Many many post - use the search option top right , you'll find more answers than you required

Team Heko for me, no problems, no noise , no water ingress. Look good, no drilling holes

 

[Meoncoast]

Have had both, preference Heko

 

[Eric1]

Thanks for the Heko recommendations, but I am leaning towards the VW stick ons. Fitting seems simpler and feedack suggests they may be more functional, even if less attractive

 

[acer]

Thanks for the Heko recommendations, but I am leaning towards the VW stick ons. Fitting seems simpler and feedack suggests they may be more functional, even if less attractive

I had the stick on variety on my 5.1. On my 6.1 they fitted the ‘in-channel’ clippy things (not sure of the correct name). I had repeated problems with the window not closing. I reverted back to stick-on and much prefer them. They have a wider profile that some don’t like, if they are after a slick look, but I think that the wider profile means more air flow and protection from rain / drips when trying to stay cool during hot wet weather. We often open the windows 3 inches in full rain when cooking, or in de-mist mode first thing in the morning.

 

[Eric1]

I took delivery of my 2021 Ocean today! And guess what? It already has deflectors fitted! The VW stick on kind. Looks good. Thanks to all for your help

 

[Perfectos]

I took delivery of my 2021 Ocean today! And guess what? It already has deflectors fitted! The VW stick on kind. Looks good. Thanks to all for your help

Photos ?