If you look at the performance of active managers as a whole relative to their benchmark index, it’s a zero sum game. The sum of the outperformance minus the sum of the underperformance is zero. It cannot be otherwise - for every buyer there is a seller.
An Index tracker, tracking the same benchmark index, will beat the average active manager, because the charges are lower. Again it cannot be otherwise.
So if you are going the active route you have to find a fund manager who is consistently better than average. Or pay an IFA who “knows the good ones “
Well good luck with that. Neil Woodford was mentioned earlier. He had a good track record with Invesco Perpetual over many years then he started his own fund, championed by Hargreaves Lansdown, and many IFA‘s. A lot of people lost their life savings when the fund went bust.
Jack Bogle, founder of Vanguard, makes the case for Index trackers much better than I ever could, so all I can say is read his book with an open mind.
Then, if you still decide to go the IFA / active fund manager route, fine, it’s your money at the end of the day. At least you will be aware that your chances of beating passive investors are not good.