Cracked EGR Pipe

Listers by any chance ? All sounds very familiar- basically the dealers can do work without authority but they risk the claim being declined by VW finance (All in provider), so basically they won’t budge without pre-approval, even if they have had the same repair approved previously for another customer.
Not the Same dealer, but the same VW BS.

VW could quite easily pre approve certain repairs to known faulty parts, particularly as they will have world wide failure figures for particular parts and let’s face it the part is cheap to make by the Million.

VW just choose to make it a laborious task for the customer and Dealer alike.
Dealers under the threat they won’t get paid , customers between a rock and a hard place.

I will have spent the best part of a day in the dealers waiting for what could have been replaced in an Hour !

No wonder Dealers charge £200 an hour Labour !

Maybe VW should consider how much the customer looses whilst dealing with the BS of VW systems, waiting for approval to fix known faulty parts.

Shame on VW, I think they could do better, but won’t
 
Got the same cracked EGR pipe issue so hijacking this thread in search for advice.

Somewhere while going down the west coast on the NC500 the rear EGR pipe decided this was absolutely the perfect opportunity to burst. Fortunately, the split didn’t grow and we got home otherwise unscathed. But what a trip – 2000k miles and the most enormous fun.

No warranty on my van, so I now have the task of replacing the pesky pipe .. kit on order from VWvanpartsdirect and luckily one of the Erwin chapters I managed to download was for replacing the EGR rear pipe :) but there wasn’t time to grab the other cross-referenced chapters before the cutoff kicked-in and everyone’s access got terminated :(

From the chapter I have, the steps involved don’t appear especially complex, but if anyone has done this on a 204PS Ocean I’d be grateful for any insights especially aspects from chapters I don’t have.

Remove expansion tank – should be straightforward, assuming I’m able to plug the expansion hose on the underside quickly and stop too much coolant from the top half of the system escaping – wine cork or conical bung might do the trick.

Remove gearbox oil cooler with attached coolant hoses and lay aside – presumably this means remove the bolts (from above I can only see two) holding the cooler while leaving the hoses with oil in still connected allowing it to be moved to one side and make space. With the expansion tank out of the way hopefully reaching the bolt next to the EGR cooler through the maze of pipework above becomes easier.

Loosen selector lever cable on gearbox only and lay aside – haven’t yet put the van in the air to find out how the cable is attached, but once I can hopefully it’ll be evident, although fully expect it also won’t be simple as not much seems designed to make anything easy in the slightest.

It then goes on to explain removing the split pipe has to be done from above and below, and new pipe must be installed free of stress – presumably the pipe needs stretching slightly before everything aligns.

To achieve this start all bolts hand tight and tighten them diagonally and alternately thereafter - the way I ended up interpreting this is, as the bolts are located diagonally in the flanges anyway, first partially tighten the two on one flange and then the two on the other. Then, in the same sequence as you would a road wheel, tighten each alternately to 20Nm i.e. in the sequence below. Can anyone confirm this is the right/wrong approach?

After which aligning the pipe requires loosening both bolts going into the EGR valve and retightening them, followed by the two in the exhaust manifold, then refit everything and top up coolant with G10 Evo.

Advice will be much welcomed!

1791656709323.png

IMG_2118.PNG
 
Managed in the end to replace the pipe from above after taking off the battery partition and expansion tank. Didn't have to disconnect the gearbox cooler or DSG cable. This is how;

Tools for removing and fitting the pipe are a 3/8" drive flexi-head stubby ratchet, a couple of 3/8" drive wobble extension bars and a 3/8" M10 spline socket, and some blu-tack. Can't be done with 1/2" drive tools as they are too bulky. There's only room for one hand behind the engine and wobble bars make aligning the spline socket with the screw heads easier than trying to use a universal joint.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B002HMRV38?ref=ppx_yo2ov_dt_b_fed_asin_title
https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B0797VYMVL?ref=ppx_yo2ov_dt_b_fed_asin_title
https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B08LQWG1ZZ?ref=ppx_yo2ov_dt_b_fed_asin_title

The really difficult screw is #4 (picture in previous post) but this can be reached with a 125mm wobble extension, the narrow shaft of which just fits between the underside of the EGR pipe and the top of the coolant pipe on the gearbox oil cooler.

Screw #2 requires a 75mm wobble extension to allow the ratchet head to clear the brake pipes.

Screws #1 #3 can be reached using just the spline socket and pivoting the ratchet head back on itself.

When fitting the new pipe use blu-tack for sticking screws #4 and #2 to the spline socket, otherwise its almost guaranteed they're going to fall out. These screws are stainless, which means they don't rust solid in the exhaust manifold, but also means a magnetic spline socket isn't much help.

I don't have a 3/8" torque wrench so I did up a bolt on something else to 20Nm first with my 1/2" torque wrench and then with the 3/8" ratchet, then replicated the effort required as near as I could fitting the pipe. Tightened the screws in the sequence stipulated by VW starting with the two going into the rear of the EGR valve.

Getting the new pipe in position with gaskets attached is a fiddle so stuff a towel or something down the back of the engine to catch anything that comes adrift, and be prepared for loosing chucks of skin on hose clips etc.

Hopefully this will be of help to anyone with the same issue.

Siphon coolant from the expansion tank and pour it back afterwards. There is/must be a thermostatic valve stopping the head of coolant in the radiator forcing coolant out of the exposed end of the connecting pipe. No plug required.

IMG_2163.jpegIMG_2177.jpeg

IMG_2184.jpeg

IMG_2185.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Managed in the end to replace the pipe from above after taking off the battery partition and expansion tank. Didn't have to disconnect the gearbox cooler or DSG cable. This is how;

Tools for removing and fitting the pipe are a 3/8" drive flexi-head stubby ratchet, a couple of 3/8" drive wobble extension bars and a 3/8" M10 spline socket, and some blu-tack. Can't be done with 1/2" drive tools as they are too bulky. There's only room for one hand behind the engine and wobble bars make aligning the spline socket with the screw heads easier than trying to use a universal joint.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B002HMRV38?ref=ppx_yo2ov_dt_b_fed_asin_title
https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B0797VYMVL?ref=ppx_yo2ov_dt_b_fed_asin_title
https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B08LQWG1ZZ?ref=ppx_yo2ov_dt_b_fed_asin_title

The really difficult screw is #4 (picture in previous post) but this can be reached with a 125mm wobble extension, the narrow shaft of which just fits between the underside of the EGR pipe and the top of the coolant pipe on the gearbox oil cooler.

Screw #2 requires a 75mm wobble extension to allow the ratchet head to clear the brake pipes.

Screws #1 #3 can be reached using just the spline socket and pivoting the ratchet head back on itself.

When fitting the new pipe use blu-tack for sticking screws #4 and #2 to the spline socket, otherwise its almost guaranteed they're going to fall out. These screws are stainless, which means they don't rust solid in the exhaust manifold, but also means a magnetic spline socket isn't much help.

I don't have a 3/8" torque wrench so I did up a bolt on something else to 20Nm first with my 1/2" torque wrench and then with the 3/8" ratchet, then replicated the effort required as near as I could fitting the pipe. Tightened the screws in the sequence stipulated by VW starting with the two going into the rear of the EGR valve.

Getting the new pipe in position with gaskets attached is a fiddle so stuff a towel or something down the back of the engine to catch anything that comes adrift, and be prepared for loosing chucks of skin on hose clips etc.

Hopefully this will be of help to anyone with the same issue.

View attachment 152956View attachment 152957

View attachment 152958

View attachment 152959
Congrats on your DIY, great write up.
 
Is this a good thread for anyone to find it, perhaps in the resources section might be better No idea how to facilitate this.
You could start a new thread in the resources section by posting your content in the new thread.

Go to the resources section and add new resource - see image below (resources screen) then look for the "add resource "

IMG_1426.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Simple answer, get the EGR deleted. It’s more trouble that it’s worth.
 
My mate said delete the EGR - they're more trouble than they're worth. Me thinks, wiser to keep it standard and stay safe from future MOT rules not to say serious agro if caught without one by German police. Anyway, it runs fine with the EGR so why alter something that works.

Pipe and EGR valve - not super clean perhaps but nothing much to complain about at 61k miles IMO. The probe hasn't been cleaned/touched - this is how it was.

When I removed the split EGR pipe, all four screws were barely nipped up, definitely not to 20Nm. Took no effort at all freeing them. Continual changes in temperature I suspect gradually loosened them and the pipe would have been ever so slightly able to vibrate. Whether this caused it to split is anyones guess but can't have helped the situation.

IMG_2192.jpeg

IMG_2194.jpeg
 
Back
Top