Hi Perfectos - thank you for your comprehensive and useful reply. I had missed the latest discussion you've linked to.
To your questions/comments :
Yes, it certainly does seem they they are misleading and that I was right to question their position. However it is now clear from the video and pics that the seal is leaking again (front seal next to cambelt.) As a side note they didn't sent the video/report or pics through to me earlier today - I only eventually got them because when picking up I saw the 360 video Inspection referenced as a zero cost line item on my invoice and asked for it to be sent to me. Apparently "they forgot earlier.....!"
Annoyingly I also now realise that the front seal was changed 2 years and 1 month ago under warranty and so falls outside their 2 year parts/work guarantee...!
It's not dripping but this leak has thrown an oil mist around and so risks contaminating the cam belt. I know it a very recent leak within the last couple of month / under 1k miles, as I had the van on ramps swapping wheels around and made a point of having a look whilst visibility was good.
As you also said they are very good at trying to double charge. They have quoted £1111 for the seal and said it would be £700 more for cambelt done at the same time. When I pointed out it was overlapping work, they said they could potentially reduce the cost a bit. I'm sure a good indipendant will take a more sensible approach.
Aside from the above, I've really lost faith in this dealership given that the other elements of the day were
- forget to send me the report ( as mentioned )
- have told me the washer fluid is leaking from a split hose behidn the bumper, but it'll cost me £198 for them to "investigate." It seems to me they have already know it's a split pipe, so they want me to pay to be retold that and for the pleasure of them presenting me with an unknown size of repair bill on top... Why are they trying to mess me about and not just giving a figure!?
-They said 2 tyres need changing even though they are at 4.5mm. Their suggeted replacments are summer tyres - even though I have identical all season tyres on all 4 corners.
-They told me that the DSG oil needs changing. I pointed out that I had got THEM to change it already at 40k miles, which they did, I'm now at 57k and so it isn't due until 80k. The response was "oh, ..."
At this point I think I'm going to be looking for an independent to quote on fixing the leak and probably do the belt and water pump at the same time. I know it's early for the belt, but maybe worth looking at the extra cost for those whilst they are "in there." A quick google suggests VRT in Slough, which is local to me.
At 57k and 7 years old it's time to switch to the independents. I was only still using main dealer network because of the all-in service/breakdown/warranty package did made some sense - but now I'm no longer willing to entertain the above. Today I used my last service from the package and it was my last visit there.