Are prices due to crash?

Many will just want to cut their losses. Especially given the grim economic forecasts going forward.

Well yes but what I’m saying is PCP gives the customer protection against hyper depreciation in that they have the option to give the car back and walk away.
 
That‘s a contradiction surely. You say that there are no advantages to the customer with PCP then go on to say everyone is handing their keys back, presumably because the car is worth less than the guaranteed minimum future value.
In which case PCP has worked in the customer’s favour and it’s the lender who takes the hit.
Not sure it’s a contradiction?

The ‘buyer’ has already paid the depreciation curve plus financing rates? Which are part of the calculus of the monthly payments.

Which is why it now costs £650 PCM to lease a little Honda e. The depreciation curve on EVs just steepened sharply.
 
That‘s a contradiction surely. You say that there are no advantages to the customer with PCP then go on to say everyone is handing their keys back, presumably because the car is worth less than the guaranteed minimum future value.
In which case PCP has worked in the customer’s favour and it’s the lender who takes the hit.
Also, the no advantages was a quote from another poster.

Personally, I buy my cars outright. Except when my business leases me an EV for tax breaks.

Or when VW give me actually free money at 0% when risk free is north if 5%.

But, I recognise they are gifting me this money because the economics of California ownership just shifted considerably.

It’s the ultimate discretionary spend after a watch.
 
There's some good deals out there - but it all depends on own personal circumstance. That's why it's always tough to do a blanket 'getting finance is a stupid move'. For many (most), having 75k sat around isn't a thing. There's a reason the majority of the ownership base aren't 25 year olds.

I'd wager that if you put each age demographic on a chart, you'd see a clear trend of the majority of owners being on the 45-65 age range, and a very clear trend of PCP deals on ages below that.

For us, the PCP worked out great. When we got our Ocean we were in our late 20's, just got our first house, and had a family on the way; we most certainly didn't have a stack of money. We watched the market for a year or more, before seeing an opportunity just as C19 hit, and to do it, we needed finance. It's worked out well for us.

The van's depreciated £2k, and so the majority of what we've put in has gone straight into equity, with a small amount being lost on depreciation and interest. And that interest cost could easily be covered through the price inflation if we were to have waited, stacked and got an equivalent Cali now.

Not saying the above is every case; far from it; it's how finance providers make a profit. But ultimately it's all down to personal circumstance as to whether it makes sense to you or not.

The real shame is when individuals aren't able or supported to make calculated decisions.
 
Many will just want to cut their losses. Especially given the grim economic forecasts going forward.
The clients of my business are mostly listed U.K. Homebuilders.

Given they represent the backbone of the U.K. economy, I would say that unless there is a wholesale and quick change in planning legislation, it looks incredibly bleak.
 
There's some good deals out there - but it all depends on own personal circumstance. That's why it's always tough to do a blanket 'getting finance is a stupid move'. For many (most), having 75k sat around isn't a thing. There's a reason the majority of the ownership base aren't 25 year olds.

I'd wager that if you put each age demographic on a chart, you'd see a clear trend of the majority of owners being on the 45-65 age range, and a very clear trend of PCP deals on ages below that.

For us, the PCP worked out great. When we got our Ocean we were in our late 20's, just got our first house, and had a family on the way; we most certainly didn't have a stack of money. We watched the market for a year or more, before seeing an opportunity just as C19 hit, and to do it, we needed finance. It's worked out well for us.

The van's depreciated £2k, and so the majority of what we've put in has gone straight into equity, with a small amount being lost on depreciation and interest. And that interest cost could easily be covered through the price inflation if we were to have waited, stacked and got an equivalent Cali now.

Not saying the above is every case; far from it; it's how finance providers make a profit. But ultimately it's all down to personal circumstance as to whether it makes sense to you or not.

The real shame is when individuals aren't able or supported to make calculated decisions.
Absolutely there are always exceptions. And wise people seize those advantages.

My observation is the overall economics of car ownership. And why the game has changed.

Covid, QE2 etc were exceptional times. We’re seeing the aftermath now.
 
Cash is king.

I have tried hard to understand the financial benefits (to the consumer) of PCP and have miserably failed.

The clients of my business are mostly listed U.K. Homebuilders.

Given they represent the backbone of the U.K. economy, I would say that unless there is a wholesale and quick change in planning legislation, it looks incredibly bleak.
I work in the commercial market (architecture) and work is busy
 
I work in the commercial market (architecture) and work is busy
All the top 10 UK Homebuilders are enforcing discounts on their contracts with the trades building them.

And whilst they are putting up the superstructure & making them watertight, they aren’t finishing them. Nothing past first fix.

Their Q1 & beyond forecasts are pretty grim. Beyond stock plots, nothing is shifting.

That said, the current mortgage rate war will eventually filter through into sales volumes.
 
I work in the commercial market (architecture) and work is busy

That sounds about right.
Domestic/Private work drying up, commercial installations remain strong. Not surprising considering how much material costs have risen. It’s an odd time in the building sector as vast parts still have worker shortages. Good skilled labour is hard to find…
 
That sounds about right.
Domestic/Private work drying up, commercial installations remain strong. Not surprising considering how much material costs have risen. It’s an odd time in the building sector as vast parts still have worker shortages. Good skilled labour is hard to find…
Cost of raw materials will rise even more in next few months.
 
At least now we have the option to make a bit of money from cash savings again.

My bank offers 4% - limited to three withdrawals per year and has a quirky regular savings account giving 6.25% - limited to £400 per month.

It only just beats inflation (3.9%), but keeping a bit of cash to hand is no longer costing anything.

Having transitioned from a saver to borrower shortly after the financial crisis, I’m now rapidly transitioning back to being a saver.
 
At least now we have the option to make a bit of money from cash savings again.

My bank offers 4% - limited to three withdrawals per year and has a quirky regular savings account giving 6.25% - limited to £400 per month.

It only just beats inflation (3.9%), but keeping a bit of cash to hand is no longer costing anything.

Having transitioned from a saver to borrower shortly after the financial crisis, I’m now rapidly transitioning back to being a saver.

My wife has a Stocks and Shares ISA with Fidelity which was 100% in an S&P 500 tracker.
About end of September I‘m getting uneasy about the way the S&P kept going up. The way I looked at it the valuation was based on everyone driving a Tesla, changing their iPhone every two year and everything we bought would have an Nvidia chip in it etc.etc.
In short it was overvalued.
So we sold and bought a one year bond with Mansfield Building Society paying 6% interest.
The S&P has put on another 10% since then. So a disastrous decision.
Well maybe. Give it time. I still think the S&P is way overvalued.
So there you go, that’s my hot tip for 2024, sell the S&P and buy the FTSE. But be warned. I’m a useless tipster.
 
My wife has a Stocks and Shares ISA with Fidelity which was 100% in an S&P 500 tracker.
About end of September I‘m getting uneasy about the way the S&P kept going up. The way I looked at it the valuation was based on everyone driving a Tesla, changing their iPhone every two year and everything we bought would have an Nvidia chip in it etc.etc.
In short it was overvalued.
So we sold and bought a one year bond with Mansfield Building Society paying 6% interest.
The S&P has put on another 10% since then. So a disastrous decision.
Well maybe. Give it time. I still think the S&P is way overvalued.
So there you go, that’s my hot tip for 2024, sell the S&P and buy the FTSE. But be warned. I’m a useless tipster.
My 401k retirement fund is locked in with TIAA Cref. I have always been a conservative investor and when I hit 55 reduced my stocks weighting to 50% with a move away from tech heavy stocks to S&P. The rate of increase in the fund has been nothing but phenomenal in the last 6 months, steaming past the pre covid highs, but it does make me uneasy. Luckily the US economy is going gangbusters and is in a lot stronger position than the UK or Eurozone. I'm not too worried. But being 5 years away from taking formal retirement I will likely drop to 30% and preserve those gains.
 
I'm not too worried. But being 5 years away from taking formal retirement I will likely drop to 30% and preserve those gains.
I have always thought this approach too conservative
Of course markets could drop, that’s a given with markets and why they say only invest for long term, more than 5 years. I read into that that not needing the capital for at least 5 years because it gives chance of recovery and over longer term stock market always out paces any other type of investment
So in your case you have 5 years to retirement and unless you plan to lock it all into an annuity or semi cash may live until say 80
That’s a long time for investments to be allowed to run whilst only taking a small percentage of it each year
Let me clearly state I am not a financial advisor or expert, just an interested investor with a stake in the game
No risk no gain, and most People get confused on the concept of risks and thus play safe, perhaps too much so
See you down the food bank
:D
 
I have always thought this approach too conservative
Of course markets could drop, that’s a given with markets and why they say only invest for long term, more than 5 years. I read into that that not needing the capital for at least 5 years because it gives chance of recovery and over longer term stock market always out paces any other type of investment
So in your case you have 5 years to retirement and unless you plan to lock it all into an annuity or semi cash may live until say 80
That’s a long time for investments to be allowed to run whilst only taking a small percentage of it each year
Let me clearly state I am not a financial advisor or expert, just an interested investor with a stake in the game
No risk no gain, and most People get confused on the concept of risks and thus play safe, perhaps too much so
See you down the food bank
:D
Yes, I will be converting it to an annuity when I hit 65. During Covid the fund dropped 30%. I want to preserve the record gains I have now, which is more than enough to keep me in the luxury to which I've become accustomed :). I think it's too tempting to be aggressive and after the recent dip I know how quickly the floor can fall out from under the nest egg.
 
My 401k retirement fund is locked in with TIAA Cref. I have always been a conservative investor and when I hit 55 reduced my stocks weighting to 50% with a move away from tech heavy stocks to S&P. The rate of increase in the fund has been nothing but phenomenal in the last 6 months, steaming past the pre covid highs, but it does make me uneasy. Luckily the US economy is going gangbusters and is in a lot stronger position than the UK or Eurozone. I'm not too worried. But being 5 years away from taking formal retirement I will likely drop to 30% and preserve those gains.

Hmm, let’s hope nobody going to the food bank.
I never worry when markets are going down but I fret when they keep going up. Be fearful when others are greedy and all that.
The S&P is on a p/e of 24 and a dividend yield of 1.5%, FTSE is on a p/e of 12 and a dividend yield of 4%. So FTSE is twice as cheap, maybe for good reason. Time will tell.
Anyway I’m going to sit on the sidelines as far as the S&P is concerned. Maybe it will keep going up and I’ll never get back in and regret it for evermore. But hey, you have to make a call and I‘ve made mine.
 
That’s perfectly reasonable based on your circumstances and risk tolerance and availability of other funds / income.
I was just saying that whilst it is safer than in the market it will likely give less performance. If that meets your goals then you are satisfied and a lucky man
Best wishes for the future
 
Hmm, let’s hope nobody going to the food bank.
I never worry when markets are going down but I fret when they keep going up. Be fearful when others are greedy and all that.
The S&P is on a p/e of 24 and a dividend yield of 1.5%, FTSE is on a p/e of 12 and a dividend yield of 4%. So FTSE is twice as cheap, maybe for good reason. Time will tell.
Anyway I’m going to sit on the sidelines as far as the S&P is concerned. Maybe it will keep going up and I’ll never get back in and regret it for evermore. But hey, you have to make a call and I‘ve made mine.
Stock market Investments are just State endorsed gambling. Preempting the market is better left to the professionals and by the time Joe Public knows anything the big players are long gone. This is why I prefer to be less aggressive and keep my full head of hair with very little grey.
 
I moved more across to income funds as the UK market has been pretty flat. Having a fund for 5yrs with no accumulation and monthly cost was starting to grind so I had a purge back in October. At least an income can offset the yo-yoing prices
 
My 401k retirement fund is locked in with TIAA Cref. I have always been a conservative investor and when I hit 55 reduced my stocks weighting to 50% with a move away from tech heavy stocks to S&P. The rate of increase in the fund has been nothing but phenomenal in the last 6 months, steaming past the pre covid highs, but it does make me uneasy. Luckily the US economy is going gangbusters and is in a lot stronger position than the UK or Eurozone. I'm not too worried. But being 5 years away from taking formal retirement I will likely drop to 30% and preserve those gains.

I take yet another different approach.
16% US stocks
16% Europe stocks (exc UK)
16% Japan stocks
16% Pacific stocks (exc Japan)
16% emerging markets
20% UK stocks (because I’m a patriot)

About three have risen by ~20% this year (including the US) and about three have risen by ~5% (including the UK). But that’s fine. The stellar compensate for the laggards, and I’ll just leave it all as it is.

All the funds are income which give ~3.5%. I had been taking the cash, but now just leave it within the ISA envelope. I only get 3.35% interest, but that’s fine. It is good to have a little stash of free cash for guilt free spending.

We hope to expand our ISA wrapper by the full £40,000 per year for the next five years at least, and by that time with retirement looming it should be giving us at least £10,000 per year in dividends: an annual guilt free tax free cash bonanza.
 
I take yet another different approach.
16% US stocks
16% Europe stocks (exc UK)
16% Japan stocks
16% Pacific stocks (exc Japan)
16% emerging markets
20% UK stocks (because I’m a patriot)

About three have risen by ~20% this year (including the US) and about three have risen by ~5% (including the UK). But that’s fine. The stellar compensate for the laggards, and I’ll just leave it all as it is.

All the funds are income which give ~3.5%. I had been taking the cash, but now just leave it within the ISA envelope. I only get 3.35% interest, but that’s fine. It is good to have a little stash of free cash for guilt free spending.

We hope to expand our ISA wrapper by the full £40,000 per year for the next five years at least, and by that time with retirement looming it should be giving us at least £10,000 per year in dividends: an annual guilt free tax free cash bonanza.

Good man. I never liked your idea of taking the dividends out of the ISA. 3.35% on cash ain’t bad.
 
Good man. I never liked your idea of taking the dividends out of the ISA. 3.35% on cash ain’t bad.

It is highly illogical. It would be better to take the cash and put it into my 4% Lloyds account - even if I have to pay tax on any additional interest. But best sense would to reinvest and sell if I want some cash. But somehow that wouldn’t feel so guilt free.
 
We'll be seeing @Amarillo's Spring WBAC valuation before this thread gets back on topic.... My past 205GTi beats the 309 diesel reminiscing hands down. Wasn't bought on PCP and would have been a great investment if someone had given me that tip and I could've afforded to mothball it.
 
My only investment in shares is BAE Systems, hitting a high today with a 11.27% , 30 day rise and just under 36% for the past year.
They did drop 20% in one day though in 2002, eek!
 
My only investment in shares is BAE Systems, hitting a high today with a 11.27% , 30 day rise and just under 36% for the past year.
They did drop 20% in one day though in 2002, eek!

I think that makes you the champ, unless someone has some Rolls-Royce which is up er 186.87% over the past year.
 
Back
Top