Amarillo
Tom
Super Poster
VIP Member
My ISA lost about 2% last year.
I've noticed I can get 5.8% in a savings account if I lock it away for a year, or at least 4% if I need instant access...
My ISA lost about 2% last year.
I've noticed I can get 5.8% in a savings account if I lock it away for a year, or at least 4% if I need instant access...
You shouldn’t go far wrong with that.I have crunched the numbers, and putting excess cash each month into a stocks and shares ISA rather than overpaying the mortgage is almost certainly going to be more advantageous.
It would be more of a gamble to increase borrowing to put a lump sum into an investment account as CGT would eat away at any profit.
So, it seems likely that come November and we remortgage, we shall be paying interest only and stuffing up to £40,000 each year into our stocks and shares ISAs. Historically we have achieved 7.5% growth, and so long as we can do better than 4.6% per year over 5 years it will be the right decision.
You shouldn’t go far wrong with that.
The p/e of the FTSE100 Index, for example, is 11.56 today. If you invert that, gives you an earnings yield of 8.65%, of which 3.92% is paid out in dividends.
That looks fair value. stay the course and you will do fine.
Or in 5 years I could remortgage again and go for a ten year repayment strategy. We might find ourselves paying school fees in the not too distant future.
You’ve spent years saving hard and investing money to give a large portion to a school…?
Crazy.
Totally crazy.
These are the choices:
1. Intensive tutoring and hope to get into one of the neighbouring borough’s grammar schools.
2. Pay fees of ~£9,000 per year per child for seven years.
3. Go to the local school where children spit at their teachers and stab each other.
My son has just finished his A levels at the local 6th Form College. We have paid for a maths tutor for the past 2 years to help him. However, he was the only one from 6th form with the tutor, ALL his other students were from the local highly rated private school with fees of 10k a year. I wouldn't be happy sending my child to a private school that then needed extra maths lessons paid for. The tutor told me the level of teaching at the 6th form was far higher than the private school.2. Pay fees of ~£9,000 per year per child for seven years.
My son has just finished his A levels at the local 6th Form College. We have paid for a maths tutor for the past 2 years to help him. However, he was the only one from 6th form with the tutor, ALL his other students were from the local highly rated private school with fees of 10k a year. I wouldn't be happy sending my child to a private school that then needed extra maths lessons paid for. The tutor told me the level of teaching at the 6th form was far higher than the private school.
How many children have been stabbed in the last 3 years at the local comprehensive…?
Totally crazy.
These are the choices:
3. Go to the local school where children spit at their teachers and stab each other.
Private schools only buy you one thing and it is not better teaching. In fact what you buy is QA the quotient of aspiration.My son has just finished his A levels at the local 6th Form College. We have paid for a maths tutor for the past 2 years to help him. However, he was the only one from 6th form with the tutor, ALL his other students were from the local highly rated private school with fees of 10k a year. I wouldn't be happy sending my child to a private school that then needed extra maths lessons paid for. The tutor told me the level of teaching at the 6th form was far higher than the private school.
And come out of it street wise having learnt about the real world, where people don't get houses bought for them & live off trust funds.
If the schools are so bad take your £18k per year in fees and spend it mortgage payments on a house where schools are better, there's no point owning 15 buy to lets and a semi in London if it means its not safe to go to school.
Private schools only buy you one thing and it is not better teaching. In fact what you buy is QA the quotient of aspiration.
All children that attend private school have, by definition almost, aspirational parents. Parents that care about the benefits of education. The average QA is high in a private school.
In a comprehensive school you have highly aspirational families, you also have families that don’t give a hoot about education. The average is lower than in a private school.
The QA is fundamental to the ethos of a school, it’s the second most important factor. It’s the thing that encourages kids to strive for better. The first is the headteacher. A good one makes a school and a bad one can break it.
This is why grammar school are so bad/good. They drive aspirational parents to one end and lower completely the average QA of the comprehensive.
Just google the news for some top private schools.
Harrow – teachers son stabbed student
St Pauls - 2 former staff members being investigated for historic sex abuse
Eton House - master convicted of child sex offences.
I can't see the appeal myself......
Only one state school makes it to the top 100 in this league table by GCSE results.
Thats skewed statistics though. If you don't stand a chance of getting any GCSEs you are not going to get into the private school in the first place.
If say the private school only accepts pupils in the top 20% then the only fair comparison would be with the results from pupils in the same top 20% that went to state school.
Try Googling ‘Top Footballers’, you will come away with a skewed impression that all Sunday league footballers are being paid ridiculous amounts of money. Same with private schools.Thats skewed statistics though. If you don't stand a chance of getting any GCSEs you are not going to get into the private school in the first place.
If say the private school only accepts pupils in the top 20% then the only fair comparison would be with the results from pupils in the same top 20% that went to state school.
1) class sizes predominantly assist the teacher, so yes there is a benefit, the teacher has less marking time so more planning time. The quality of learning isn’t affected particularly. I’ve taught bottom set classes with 12 students that were a nightmare to teach, the average level of aspiration was not good. They were nice kids though.Almost completely agree, but you have missed three things.
1. Private school pupils benefit from smaller class sizes.
2. You are unlikely to find inexperienced teachers in private schools
3. Private schools offer scholarships and bursaries to bright pupils whose parents might not be able to afford the fees. The benefit of having a rich dim child sitting next to a poor bright child should not be underestimated (for the rich dim child).
1) class sizes predominantly assist the teacher, so yes there is a benefit, the teacher has less marking time so more planning time. The quality of learning isn’t affected particularly. I’ve taught bottom set classes with 12 students that were a nightmare to teach, the average level of aspiration was not good. They were nice kids though.
2) There is absolutely no difference in the quality of teaching, they all come from the same pool. I think that if there were, the difference would be reversed. Excellent teachers can often be ideologically welded to comprehensive education, they are passionate about making a difference.
3) I don’t know about bursaries.
Again its a case of you can show whatever you want with statistics.6.5% of British pupils attend private school.
By age 25 Britons with a private education earn 17% more.
By age 42 this has widened to 21% for women and 42% for men.
Careful using percentages like that; it's meaningless without knowing how many applicants there are. I would be surprised if the rate of success for private schoolers isn't higher than for state schoolers.4% of Oxbridge entrants are private schoolers compared to around 70% of state schoolers (the remaining 26% are, presumably, overseas students). This suggests that a student is more likely to get into Oxford or Cambridge if they attend state school.
Within my inner circle of friends. Two were privately educated. One now owns a strip club and the other is a teacher at a private school.
I think the education was lost on these two…
Another close couple, both of whom were state educated, and ended up with doctorates in their fields of study, Have sent their boys private. So far the eldest has his leg broken in two places in a friendly game of lunchtime football (it’s complete changed the poor kid)and their youngest has behavioural problems.
It will be interesting to see how our boys turn out in years to come, as we’ve sent ours to the local state school and happy with his progress, learning and maturity.
I’m convinced, parental guidance/support is a much higher factor than what school they attend. Hence why I work part-time and believe being around to support them will pay dividends in the long run…
The VW California Club is the worlds largest resource for all owners and enthusiasts of VW California campervans.