Brake wear false indication

S

spitzie

Messages
98
Location
Hampshire
Vehicle
T6 Ocean 204
I drove my 2016 Cali, 300 miles to Manchester without issue. Parked up for a few hours and then started to come home. The moment I reversed out off the parking space, the check brake wear indicator came on. Pulled into another parking space, looked at the brakes (all discs and pads have been replaced in the last 9 months with Brembo), Drove round the car park a few times testing the brakes, the indicator had gone off and the Cali seemed to be stopping as normal.
Drove home sedately, with the indicator coming on intermittently for a few minutes at a time.
Phoned the garage who replaced the brakes and they booked it in to have a look today. They checked the pad and discs, and found nothing wrong. Put the Cali on roller and tested the brakes, everything fine. The indictor didn't come on at all.
I go to collect the Cali and as soon and I start the drive away the indictor comes on. Lucky the mechanic was watching with coffee, and tells me the right reverse light didn't work. A little testing to confirm and also find the right indicator has shorted to the right rear light.

Looks like I'm fixing a light cluster now, sometimes I wonder how helpful CANBUS actually is.

View attachment PXL_20261117_105704794.jpg
 
I drove my 2016 Cali, 300 miles to Manchester without issue. Parked up for a few hours and then started to come home. The moment I reversed out off the parking space, the check brake wear indicator came on. Pulled into another parking space, looked at the brakes (all discs and pads have been replaced in the last 9 months with Brembo), Drove round the car park a few times testing the brakes, the indicator had gone off and the Cali seemed to be stopping as normal.
Drove home sedately, with the indicator coming on intermittently for a few minutes at a time.
Phoned the garage who replaced the brakes and they booked it in to have a look today. They checked the pad and discs, and found nothing wrong. Put the Cali on roller and tested the brakes, everything fine. The indictor didn't come on at all.
I go to collect the Cali and as soon and I start the drive away the indictor comes on. Lucky the mechanic was watching with coffee, and tells me the right reverse light didn't work. A little testing to confirm and also find the right indicator has shorted to the right rear light.

Looks like I'm fixing a light cluster now, sometimes I wonder how helpful CANBUS actually is.

View attachment 153311
It will be an earthing issue, either bad or missing earth connection, the rear right lamp cluster and rear brake pad warning share the same ground and when the ground has an issue then then the other circuits become pseudo earth paths. You used to see this all the time on older cars with bulbs pulsing as the indicators operated, or indicators lighting up with brake pedal.
 
Looks like I'm fixing a light cluster now, sometimes I wonder how helpful CANBUS actually is.

View attachment 153311
I think the answer is “extremely “. If you’d plugged in a diagnostic package it would have told you exactly.
That said, it would be so much more helpful if the dash actually told you but then, VW wouldn’t make any money would they, bless ‘em.
 
It will be an earthing issue, either bad or missing earth connection, the rear right lamp cluster and rear brake pad warning share the same ground and when the ground has an issue then then the other circuits become pseudo earth paths. You used to see this all the time on older cars with bulbs pulsing as the indicators operated, or indicators lighting up with brake pedal.
You wouldn't know where the earth point is?

Sent from my Pixel 11 Pro XL using Tapatalk
 
I wouldn’t waste your time searching for the earth point.
Just go to each connector on the light cluster and check for power and ground.
Use a simple test light. Connect it to battery + and touch the probe to the ground connection. If it lights then you have a good earth.
Switch the lights on. Connect test light to battery - and touch the probe to the power connection, if it lights then you have power.
If non of the above work then that’s the problem. Go from there.
 
Sorry, I hope to say these are LED units and I have swapped the Left and Right units over with the problem staying on the right side of the Cali.
Hence why I looking at the earth point on the right side and not the units
 
Sorry, I hope to say these are LED units and I have swapped the Left and Right units over with the problem staying on the right side of the Cali.
Hence why I looking at the earth point on the right side and not the units
Not hop forgot
 
Sorry, I hope to say these are LED units and I have swapped the Left and Right units over with the problem staying on the right side of the Cali.
Hence why I looking at the earth point on the right side and not the units
Are the rear number plate lights working, top central brake lamp anything else not functioning?
 
Left side works correct
Brake lights work both side with High level
Rear lights work both side with number plate light
Rear fog lights work both sides
Right reverse light does not work
Right indicator flashes the rear light instead if the rear lights are on, otherwise the reverse and indicator dimly flash

To me this suggests the problem is a short in the cluster (circuit board?), except when I swapped the left and right clusters over the problem stayed on the right side.
 
Left side works correct
Brake lights work both side with High level
Rear lights work both side with number plate light
Rear fog lights work both sides
Right reverse light does not work
Right indicator flashes the rear light instead if the rear lights are on, otherwise the reverse and indicator dimly flash

To me this suggests the problem is a short in the cluster (circuit board?), except when I swapped the left and right clusters over the problem stayed on the right side.
I would say that your A-B-A test of swapping lamps side to side would suggest it isn't the rear lamp if it works on the other side, i still think this earth.

The earths are groups of wires that are all spliced to together at various places, my gut feeling is that if you have the centre brake lamp and number plate lamps working then the issue isn't at the earth stud and at one of the spices in the middle.

It really depends on your appetite, confidence and tools. For me the brake warning could mean the wire break is beyond just the lamp earth wire, but perhaps trying to put another earth wire in even temporary measure and using the cigar socket as the earth on the outer edge (carefully) - but again this depends on confidence. If the rear lamps have been off and on at all for other reasons, i would very carefully check the wire and crimp directly at the connecter entrance. A multimeter would help can can be bought very cheapy, you need one that does resistance (which they all should)
 
As I stated above, establish very quickly and easily if it’s an earth or a power problem.
If it’s an earth then simply add a new local earth to any bodywork. Done.
 
FYI.
The previous iterations of transporter have reported issues with the rear lights earth wiring, with corrosion to wires and earth points being the culprit.

Intermittent, head scratcher problem = start with earth issues
 
Last edited:
The rear cluster has a common earth, so wouldn't an earthing problem cause issues with the LED lights as well as the reverse and indicator bulbs?
 
The rear cluster has a common earth, so wouldn't an earthing problem cause issues with the LED lights as well as the reverse and indicator bulbs?
The LEDs are very low current and diodes, so they are likely to be getting ground path via the bulbs (which in turn will have a small earth path via the BCM diagnostics circuits). I think you have two options, try a alternative ground wire or buy replacement new lamp if you are convinced that is the issue, the general view is try earth first. An auto electrician should be able to resolve quicky.
 
I think the issue is the LED units? Did the OP fit them aftermarket? LEDs are normally ground side switched which this van isn’t.

OP. Try fitting standard non led bulbs to see if that cures the issue?
 
I think the issue is the LED units? Did the OP fit them aftermarket? LEDs are normally ground side switched which this van isn’t.

OP. Try fitting standard non led bulbs to see if that cures the issue?
Automotive stuff tends to positively switched, some historic reasons, better protection / diagnostics, you don't have to protect grounds, so having Mosfets act as fuses and switches on the 12v side has advantages for things like lamps that have spilt functions. Interior switch illumination is almost always ground switched & PWM'd (to give variable dimming) - you either use an existing 12v within a switch or module, or you just use one or two fuses to power them all. Where a circuit is internal (ie no exposing wiring, then it really depends on application, some systems like fuel pumps can actually switch both sides for safety reasons.
 
So after much probing with a multimeter and some clipped on flying leads. I concluded it was a dodgy earth, which I suspect is somewhere behind the right hand rear panel(not an easy job to remove).
Instead I have spliced in a 2nd earth from the cluster common earth wire to the mounting bolt on the right rear radar sensor.
Voilà, everything is working.
Thanks for all the advice.
At some point in the future(when it's warmer) I will see about fixing the original issue.

Sent from my Pixel 11 Pro XL using Tapatalk
 
Earthing point info is available (courtesy of @WelshGas ) in the resources section

"T6 EARTHING POINTS" includes t5/ 5.1/ 6 /6.1​



IMG_1497.jpeg
 

Similar threads

A
Replies
1
Views
1K
secret lemonade drinker
S
drmanhattan
Replies
13
Views
4K
calikev
calikev
I
Replies
7
Views
8K
Hotel California
H
Back
Top